In today’s fragmented media landscape, sourcing credible information has become more complex than ever before. Recently, a client reached out to ask if a source included in their daily executive news brief was legitimate. This question, though simple, highlights a critical issue in media intelligence: how do we evaluate non-mainstream or potentially biased sources?
For over 20 years, I’ve seen one constant in the media intelligence industry— communications executives, especially those at the VP level, are wary of outsourcing their CEO-level news briefs. And it’s easy to see why: as sponsors of these reports, their reputation is on the line. To succeed, the editorial judgment, timing, and content sourcing need to be flawless.
So, when the client raised the legitimacy of a particular source, our team acted quickly. The source in question—a lesser-known publication with a somewhat unconventional name—was vetted thoroughly and turned out to be a legitimate outlet, just one that operated outside the mainstream media bubble. While the situation was resolved without issue, it raised a few important points that communicators should keep in mind when dealing with an ever-growing sea of news sources.
Key Takeaways for Handling Non-Mainstream Sources
1. Mainstream Isn’t Always the Only Path
While major outlets dominate the media landscape, niche publications can often provide valuable perspectives that are overlooked by mainstream media. These sources can offer insights into specialized communities, emerging trends, or niche industries that may be more relevant to your target audience. Ignoring them may mean missing out on important discussions or innovations that aren’t covered by the bigger players.
2. Vetting Is Critical
Not all sources are created equal. One of the most valuable roles of a media monitoring partner is to thoroughly vet each source—mainstream or otherwise. Understanding the background, credibility, and potential bias of every publication is essential. An experienced agency will be able to sift through the noise, providing insights from sources that add real value, while flagging those that don’t meet quality standards.
3. Biased Sources Aren’t Necessarily Bad—But Proceed with Caution
In today’s polarized media environment, it’s common to come across sources with clear political or ideological leanings. These outlets can offer useful insights, but it’s crucial to approach them with a critical eye. As long as you understand the bias and evaluate the content accordingly, you may uncover information that centrist sources miss. However, be cautious when sharing slanted sources in reports intended for large or diverse audiences—what’s helpful for internal analysis may not be appropriate for broad distribution.
4. Unconventional Names Don’t Mean Unreliable Content
Sometimes, the legitimacy of a source is questioned purely based on its name. In this case, our client was concerned because the publication sounded informal. However, what matters most is the quality of the reporting, not the name of the outlet. If the content is accurate, aligns with your goals, and is valuable to your organization, then it’s worth including. In fact, these unconventional sources can be prime candidates for future relationship-building and outreach efforts.
Expanding Your Media Universe: Are You Missing Out?
The incident with our client made us consider: How does your organization treat sources that might be outside the mainstream? Are you embracing the potential of these non-traditional outlets, or are you limiting your media monitoring to the usual suspects?
With the explosion of niche publications, blogs, podcasts, and social media platforms, there’s a whole world of information available beyond traditional news outlets. If you’re not casting a wide enough net, you could be flying blind to valuable insights and opportunities for your brand. We’d love to hear your thoughts on how your organization navigates this ever-evolving media landscape. Do you feel confident in your source selection, or are there areas where you think you could benefit from a broader approach? Let’s start a conversation about how to stay ahead in today’s media ecosystem. Contact Us to learn more.
VIEW ALL ARTICLES